The long and short of the story, is that the court, after scrutinizing not only the Memorandum, but also the wordings of the press releases and other documents that Getty Oil and Pennzoil had issued over the course of their dealings, found Getty Oil to be "in breach" of the Memorandum of Agreement _ the document the parties had viewed as a letter of intent. Thus, a document (the letter of intent) that the parties had started out viewing as non_binding and unenforceable, had changed from being that, to being a final agreement! Pennzoil, on the other hand, ended up with บǒ billion (later settled for ū billion) from Texaco for interfering in its deal with Getty Oil.
In fact, some experts have called the LOI a document whose use is primarily advocated or promoted only by amateurs and marginal dealers or "joker_broker" types in the crude trade business, especially the overzealous sellers' agents and brokers in a desperate hurry to land some buyers. Mr. Ziad K. Abdelnour, President & CEO of Blackhawk Partners, Inc, a New York_based advisory firm to traders and suppliers of metals, minerals and crude oil commodities, calls the LOI document something that is primarily "used out on the Internet by inexperienced traders," and by "inexperienced 'intermediary seller' who is claiming to be the supplier."